From what I've read here and in the other bugs, I think that the proposition of

https://bugs.koha-community.org/bugzilla3/show_bug.cgi?id=15534 --- Comment #12 from Koha Team Lyon 3 <koha@univ-lyon3.fr> --- I'm really interested by this bug and I can try to give you my opinion and my feedback. the syspref allowonshelfholds with 3 option sounds good. I agree that we can keep the current behaviour that allows to put holds if only one item at least is borrowed (but I must say that patrons in my library don't really understand that their hold are not put on available items but only on the borrowed one). I'm looking forward to the new option to be implemented because it's really the behaviour that we expect : that patrons can put holds only if all items that can be hold are checked out. It isn't specified here but if there's items with different item types and that some of them are not defined as "holdable" in issuing rules and are on shelves but that all the "holdable" one are checked out, we should have the possibility to place an hold. And it should be the same if we have items from different branches : one that allows holds and the other not. If there's items available in the branch that doesn't allow holds, but that all the items from the branch that allows holds are checked out, patrons should be able to place a hold. I hope that I'm clear in my explanations... Sonia BOUIS -- You are receiving this mail because: You are watching all bug changes.