[Koha-devel] MARC Editor in 'stable' CVS Badly Broken

[Joshua Ferraro]

Hi Paul et al,

This morning I updated my working "stable" CVS repo to take a look 
at the recent MARC editor commits and I discovered that things are 
very badly broken:

* repeated fields are not saved separately, but under one field
	eg, 650$a$b$c 650$a$b$c becomes 650$a$a$b$b$c$c!!
	(you will not see this bug unless you have 'LabelMARCView' set
	to 'standard')

* repeating fixed fields in a previously saved record causes a 500 error
* tabindex is broken
* the back button is broken such that if you save something then go
	back your repeated 650 jumps into the 651!!
* editing a record sometimes causes fields to show up in the right
	place, but be saved in the wrong place

After 6 hours of attempting to track down the cause of these and other
bugs I didn't take notes on, I have given up. I'd like to request that
we revert the stable CVS MARC editor to the previously working
versions:

Biblio.pm 1.115.2.54
addbiblio.pl 1.52.2.40
addbiblio.tmpl (not sure, many unrelated changes committed at the
same time)

I will repeat that MARC::File::XML can handle iso-8859-1 encoding
if you specify that you're working with non-MARC21 data (and if
you have 8859 encoding, you don't have MARC21 data) IF YOUR
XML PARSER CAN HANDLE 8859 ENCODING. Someone with non-MARC21 data
should take a look at the latest Sourceforge version of 
MARC::File::XML to see how this is handled and modify Koha's editor
accordingly (I may have a chance to do this at some point, but I'm
a bit burned out on this at the moment).

Cheers,

-- 
Joshua Ferraro               VENDOR SERVICES FOR OPEN-SOURCE SOFTWARE
President, Technology       migration, training, maintenance, support
LibLime                                Featuring Koha Open-Source ILS
jmf at liblime.com |Full Demos at http://liblime.com/koha |1(888)KohaILS